I watched an episode of Dr. Oz in which he debated with another guy. ?áAs I watched this, I wondered about authority. ?áBoth of these men spoke with intelligence. Each was confident of his authority on the same topic, however, they differed in opinion. A silly question entered my mind as I watch them counter each other: would this debate be different if it were between women??á?áWould it be the same kind of debate? ?áWould the audience be able to stand watching two women act like this??á My mind then turned to Oprah Winfrey. ?áShe is one of the most important people on earth and she is cherished by millions of people. But is she considered an authority in anything? ?áMy answer to my initial questions lead to further bleak thoughts.
Later that week, I was chatting with a friend about International Women’s Week. ?áMy friend asserted a frightening, yet sincere question that she was thinking about. She felt like she could nearly give up. ?áShe stated something similar to “we women make up 52% of the world’s population, if we are not leaders of most things, then perhaps we are indeed the weaker sex.” ?áThat comment really threw me off. ?áYeah, what if? It reminded me of talks I had with my great grandmother some twenty-odd years ago.?á Granny Short would tell me to look around and see for myself: men are the best at everything.?á She observed that most women at that time cooked for their families, and yet how is it that it is the men who end up being the best cooks in the world? Why are men the chefs? ?áI think she said this to me to protect me, since she was never one to limit me. ?áI understood what she was saying, but I am glad this is not the end of the story.
So, I asked myself, where are women acting as authorities? ?áWhere are these women in my life? ?áIt is funny, because I asked that question to no one but myself. All of a sudden, a host of seriously authoritative women came out of the woodwork. ?áA friend on Facebook spontaneously reminded me of a singer I used to listen to a lot, Ani Difranco. ?áAni is a talented musician and poet that has influenced many, many people over the years in terms of music and politics. ?áShe has caused me to think a great deal about my experience. ?áShe has also inspired a great deal in me, like she has for many other women too. ?áAnd she is still involved in her craft, authoritatively.
And then there was a brief blip in thought on the subject when another friend sent me the Rebecca Black song, “Friday”. ?áMy friend sent it to me thinking I would appreciate “this really deep song” (heeheehee). ?áI did enjoy it, however not the earworm. ?áBut it made me realize that some women end up becoming great, even if they are young and lacking in authority. ?áThis is not the worst thing, I am okay with her being lucky with success.
Then another good example came to life while I watched Sarah Kay’s skilled and authoritative TED talk.?á?áOnce again, I was hopeful for women and the future.
And last but not least, I read a story of tragedy and then triumph. ?áLiz Murray was raised on the streets by drug-addicted parents, sometimes eating chap stick or toothpaste as food, missing a great deal of school and ends up beating all of odds and gets into Harvard.
If I can put aside my need to perceive what is weaker or stronger, and if I look into my own life, I see many examples of women who are authoritative. ?áIt is extremely obvious that women are kick’n it in many different realms. ?áI am almost embarrassed that I even asked the silly questions in the first place! ?áBut, it was a good exercise for me. ?áAnd I am sure I will enjoy exploring this topic further.
Tammy Schmidt, Montreal.
Comments
9 responses to “authority”
Somehow this comment ended up in the trash and I am having a hard time retrieving it. The comment was a link:
This might be of interest:
http://www.j-source.ca/english_new/detail.php?id=6319
After going to this link, I remembered that I heard something similar on CBC.
http://www.cbc.ca/thesundayedition/shows/2011/02/20/women-in-publishing—mmr-autism-scandal—phil-ochs-documentary/
What is going on here? Anyone wish to comment?
Perhaps the sharing/publishing of information is the last place that gender equality will reach… as it is really huge congealed place of power. Really, who writes the text? Who makes our world be what it is? Who has a voice?
I really do believe things are changing, but the Old Boy’s Club mentality needs to go ASAP.
I have a few female friends who are successful in journalism. Will they ever make it as leaders in this field, will they one day be the managers? I don’t know. I hope so. Are we not in a post glass ceiling age? It feels wrong to even mention it, but these can be important questions. Who has a voice? Who is considered an authority? Who cares?
In the radio interview (The CBC one you posted above) I felt that old sense of helplessness wash over me: The writer described how her annecdotal study on gender equality in magazines brought out the worst sort of misogynisitic comments in the “comments” sections of the supposedly progressive journalism sites that posted her study. It was only after the nasty words were down that non-nasty comments started to appear.
I think that we recognise that this problem exists, we feel “that helplessness” that I admit to feeling sometimes (then ignore it and plow ahead anyhow), but that we need to confront the problems. That being said, your successful female journalist friends will find a place in the right journals. I think that they will plow on and make it. It is disheartening and agrivating to see the odds, though.
Wanted to pass this on, too:
http://notesandqueries.ca/the-other-f-word-the-disappearance-of-feminism-from-our-fiction/
Thought you might appreciate this, although it’s a bit different in terms of what it’s arguing, it’s all related…
Thanks Suzan.
This well written article brings to light how women’s voice and behaviour factors into all of this. It definitely gives me a lot to think about in terms of voice.
I also think it is particularly interesting where she states that,
“Perhaps if women stopped being girls ÔÇô in life and in fiction ÔÇô perhaps if they finally grew up, these issues could be taken seriously and the wage gap may finally diminish.”
Although I am not strongly compelled to say the cause of this mess is women acting childishly, like women are the only ones allowing this, it does make me wonder how we can improve our chances.
This is right up your alley–keep going back to this article by a woman I really, really like:
http://www.tomdispatch.com/post/174918
Wow, this is a big part of it too. Thank-you Deborah!